Index Funds vs. Mutual Funds (2024)

Editorial Note: We earn a commission from partner links on Forbes Advisor. Commissions do not affect our editors' opinions or evaluations.

Mutual funds and index funds are popular options for diversifying your portfolio without having to hand pick individual stocks.

Both allow you to spread your investments across various assets and industries, decreasing your level of risk. Although these investment options are similar, investors should understand there are several key differences between them before investing their hard-earned money.

What Is a Mutual Fund?

Mutual funds are professionally managed investments that pool money from several investors. In 2022, the Investment Company Institute (ICI) reported that just over half of U.S. households owned mutual funds.

When you buy a share of a mutual fund, you purchase a slice of ownership of the fund. That slice entitles you to a proportional share of the income and capital gains the fund generates.

The fund’s investment manager invests the fund’s assets in a variety of stocks, bonds or other securities, making decisions on what to buy, sell and trade on behalf of the fund’s shareholders.

Active vs. Passive Management

Mutual funds can be actively or passively managed:

  • Actively-managed mutual funds. In an actively-managed mutual fund, an investment professional or team of portfolio managers selects the investments for the fund with the goal of outperforming a stock market benchmark. Actively managed funds typically have higher fees associated with them.
  • Passively-managed mutual funds. Passively-managed mutual funds mimic the performance of market indices. Generally through automated or mostly hands-off systems that cost less to manage, resulting in lower fees.

For those who own shares of mutual funds, retirement is the most common goal. Mutual funds are a good fit for retirement savings because they provide broad diversification. Other common goals for mutual fund investors include saving for emergencies or a child’s college education.

What Is an Index Fund?

Index funds aren’t a separate investment vehicle from mutual funds. Instead, they’re passively-managed mutual funds that track the performance of market indices, such as the or the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA).

These funds may contain all of the holdings in an index or only a representative sample. In either case, index funds strive to match the benchmark index’s performance as closely as possible.

According to ICI, 48% of households with mutual funds owned equity index funds, or index funds that invest primarily in stocks.

As opposed to actively managed mutual funds, index funds can be good choices for long-term, passive investors. In fact, billionaire Warren Buffett is a proponent of index funds for those saving for retirement because of their low costs.

Whether you’re tucking money into an employer-sponsored retirement plan like a 401(k) or an individual retirement account (IRA), the low fees associated with index funds ensure you can benefit from dividends, and the funds tend to be tax efficient because of their buy-and-hold approach.

Index Funds vs. Mutual Funds: Key Differences

Index funds and mutual funds provide portfolio diversification, but there are some significant differences to consider.

Objectives

The objective of the fund will dictate how the portfolio is managed and what investments are included.

Many mutual funds are actively managed by investment professionals with the goal of outperforming market benchmarks.

By contrast, index funds are passively-managed and designed to match their index’s performance as closely as possible.

Costs

Generally, mutual funds and index funds have relatively low fees, but index funds tend to have lower expense ratios than mutual funds.

ICI reported that the average expense ratio for actively managed equity mutual funds was 0.68%, while the average expense ratio for index funds was just 0.06%.

This means that for every $1,000 invested in an actively managed equity mutual fund, the investor pays a $6.80 fee on average. While for an index fund, investors pay an average of $0.60 for every $1,000 invested. Over time, these increased fees can add up to a significant amount, especially if the mutual fund doesn’t outperform the index fund.

Flexibility

Mutual funds are more flexible than index funds because the investment professional managing the fund can respond to market changes and change the fund’s holdings.

With an index fund, the fund only invests in securities within a specific index.

Risks

Actively-managed mutual funds can be riskier investment options than index funds.

With a portfolio manager trying to outperform the market, there’s a chance they will make poor decisions that hurt the fund’s performance.

Index FundsMutual Funds
Available SecuritiesStocks, bonds and other securitiesStocks, bonds and other securities
Investment ObjectivesTo replicate the performance of a market indexTo outperform a market benchmark
CostIndex mutual funds averaged 0.06%Mutual funds averaged 0.47%, but actively-managed equity mutual funds averaged 0.68%
ManagementPassively-managedActively-managed or passively-managed

Which is Better, Active or Passive Funds?

When it comes to index funds vs. mutual funds, fund management is a major differentiator.

An actively-managed fund can be appealing because it aims to beat the performance of market benchmarks. But when considering your options, keep in mind that even the most experienced investment professionals struggle to outperform market indices.

While some investment professionals manage to do it sometimes, their performance is inconsistent. S&P Dow Jones Indices’ scorecard compares the performance of actively-managed mutual funds to major indices.

It found that over the course of one year, 51.08% of actively-managed mutual funds underperformed the S&P 500, and 48.92% of actively-managed funds outperformed the S&P 500.* However, those numbers change dramatically over longer periods of time.

  • Over five years, just 13.49% of actively-managed funds outperformed the S&P 500*
  • Over 10 years, only 8.59% of actively-managed funds outperformed the S&P 500*

*Data as of December 31, 2022

Depending on your goals, low-cost index funds can be a smart option because the majority consistently outperform actively-managed mutual funds.

Investing for the Future

Mutual funds and index funds are popular investment options for those looking to diversify their portfolios. They both allow you to invest in many securities and industries at once, and due to their relatively low costs, they can be affordable for a wide range of investors.

Before you decide between index funds vs. mutual funds, consider your investment goals and risk tolerance.

Index funds tend to be low-cost, passive options that are well-suited for hands-off, long-term investors. Actively-managed mutual funds can be riskier and more expensive, but they have the potential for higher returns over time.

You can use investing analysis tools like Morningstar or Forbes to view detailed information on the performance and fees of different funds so you can make an informed decision.

If you aren’t sure which fund type is best for you—or if you simply want a checkup to ensure you’re on track to meet your goals—meet with a financial advisor to review your finances and develop an investment plan.

As an investment enthusiast with a deep understanding of mutual funds, index funds, and the broader financial landscape, I'd like to delve into the concepts discussed in the provided article.

Mutual funds and index funds serve as popular choices for diversifying investment portfolios without the need to select individual stocks. The article provides a comprehensive overview of these investment vehicles, covering key aspects such as management styles, objectives, costs, flexibility, and risks.

Mutual Funds:

  1. Definition: Mutual funds are professionally managed investment pools that aggregate money from multiple investors. Each investor, upon purchasing a share, becomes a fractional owner of the fund, entitling them to a proportionate share of the fund's income and capital gains.

  2. Active vs. Passive Management:

    • Actively-managed mutual funds: These funds are curated by investment professionals or portfolio managers with the aim of outperforming a market benchmark. They typically come with higher associated fees.
    • Passively-managed mutual funds: These funds mirror the performance of market indices, often through automated or hands-off systems, resulting in lower management fees.
  3. Objectives:

    • Mutual funds are commonly used for retirement savings due to their broad diversification.
    • Other goals include saving for emergencies or a child’s college education.

Index Funds:

  1. Definition: Index funds are a subset of mutual funds designed to passively track the performance of market indices, such as the S&P 500 or Dow Jones Industrial Average.

  2. Benefits:

    • Index funds are favored by long-term, passive investors for their low costs.
    • Notably, billionaire Warren Buffett recommends index funds for retirement savings due to their cost-effectiveness.
  3. Differences with Mutual Funds:

    • Objectives: Mutual funds may aim to outperform market benchmarks, while index funds strive to replicate their index's performance closely.
    • Costs: Index funds generally have lower expense ratios than mutual funds, providing cost advantages for investors.
    • Flexibility: Mutual funds are more flexible as their managers can adjust holdings in response to market changes, whereas index funds stick to specific indices.
    • Risks: Actively-managed mutual funds can be riskier due to the potential for poor decisions by portfolio managers.
  4. Comparative Data:

    • The article highlights the cost disparities, stating that the average expense ratio for actively managed equity mutual funds was 0.68%, while index funds averaged just 0.06%.

Active vs. Passive Funds:

The article discusses the major differentiator between actively-managed and passive funds, emphasizing that while actively-managed funds aim to beat market benchmarks, the majority struggle to do so consistently over time. It cites data from S&P Dow Jones Indices, indicating that over longer periods, a significant percentage of actively-managed funds underperform major indices.

Investing for the Future:

The article concludes by advising investors to consider their goals and risk tolerance when choosing between index funds and mutual funds. It suggests that index funds, with their low costs and suitability for long-term investors, can be a wise option. Additionally, it recommends using investment analysis tools and consulting with financial advisors for informed decision-making.

For a more detailed analysis of specific funds, the article suggests utilizing tools like Morningstar or Forbes to assess performance and fees, ensuring investors make well-informed decisions aligned with their financial goals.

Index Funds vs. Mutual Funds (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 5732

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Cheryll Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-12-23

Address: 4653 O'Kon Hill, Lake Juanstad, AR 65469

Phone: +494124489301

Job: Marketing Representative

Hobby: Reading, Ice skating, Foraging, BASE jumping, Hiking, Skateboarding, Kayaking

Introduction: My name is Cheryll Lueilwitz, I am a sparkling, clean, super, lucky, joyous, outstanding, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.